The question is, is she genuinely shy or just being disingenuous as a way to be sexy? I set my girl Anne (from my New Orleans crew) up with a three-way. When I took her clothes off, she whispered, "You know I'm shy". 30 seconds later she had a cock in each hand and was grinning from ear to ear. A few minutes later and she was happily getting spit roasted. No doubt it was her shyness that compelled her to keep her eyes closed so she wouldn't be embarrassed by seeing herself getting out of her oh so quickly discarded comfort zone.